In the Trenches: A Background Check Post-Mortem

A little over a month ago, I wrote about my struggle to find the right way to do a background check on a new employee. Now that I’ve successfully completed one, I thought I’d share what I learned during the experience.

First, I should say that this was one of the most stressful things I’ve had to do as a small-business owner. That may sound silly, but it’s true. After all, I had to share a lot of private information about my potential employee with the agency that did the checking. This caused me to worry. What if the company did something sinister with the information? What if it found out my prospective employee was a convicted murderer? What if — well, you get the point.

What made the process even more stressful was the fact that it takes time to get reliable results. You may be hear about “instant” searches, but those are far from comprehensive. Background checks should take a few days if they are going to be thorough. And, during that time, all an employer can do is wait and wonder.

To ease the anxiety, I strongly suggest using an agency that’s recommended by someone you know. If a friend or a colleague you trust has had a positive experience, then that should ease your mind. In my case, after I wrote my first post on this subject, I received a lot of advice in my inbox. (Of course, some of it came from people I don’t know, which didn’t help establish credibility but did at least give me some great companies to investigate.)

I followed up the most promising leads, however each one gave me different answers. One agency told me that, in order to do a credit check, I had to get interviewed by a government official at my place of business to make sure there was a legitimate reason. Another told me that wasn’t the case, because I wasn’t requesting a full credit report with details.  I was just looking for an overview of whether there were any concerns in the credit history. I found myself frustrated and confused once again.

In the end, I went with an agency called Global Business Screening. The owner left a comment on my first post, and she proved to be both easy to contact and full of helpful answers. I had to get multiple forms filled out by my prospective employee, and a few days later, I had my results. I paid $100 for a credit check and all sorts of criminal checks in multiple states.

It all came back clean. Although it’s tempting to think that conducting the background check was a waste of time and money, I disagree. Now I can feel more comfortable about allowing my new employee to handle our sensitive client data.

About Brett Snyder

Brett is the Founder and President of Cranky Concierge air travel assistance. He also writes the consumer air travel blog, The Cranky Flier.
This entry was posted in Employees and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

So is there an agency that runs a background check on background check agencies? ;)Interesting couple of posts, Brett. 


Good post, Bret. Some idle thoughts if I may.  First, as anxiety producing as background checks may be, for both you and your prospective employee, that are a part of your necessary due diligence as an a proprietor serving the public.  Part of the driving force behind these checks may be some requirement from your General Liability insurance carrier.  If so, they may offer some suggestions or, in some cases perform the checks themselves.  It is worth asking about.


Oliver - I wish I knew if there such an agency!  I couldn't find anything, so had to rely on the usual suspects like BBB, Yelp, general google searches...


  1. [...] In the Trenches: A Background Check Post-Mortem – Intuit Small Business Blog I realized that background checks were a lot more anxiety-producing than I thought would be the case. Miscellaneous none [...]